An Overview Of Trademark Acquired Distinctiveness or Secondary Meaning

Acquired Distinctiveness and Secondary Meaning in Trademark Law

Acquired distinctiveness, also known as secondary meaning, is a fundamental concept in U.S. trademark law, as articulated in the Lanham Act and further detailed in the Trademark Manual of Examining Procedure (TMEP). This concept plays a crucial role in the protection of trademarks that are not inherently distinctive, enabling them to qualify for federal registration based on their acquired identity in the minds of consumers. Here, we provide a detailed overview of this legal principle.

Conceptual Foundations: Acquired distinctiveness or secondary meaning occurs when a mark that is not distinctive by nature comes to be associated by the public with a particular source of goods or services. Essentially, through extensive and sustained use, a mark that initially serves only a descriptive purpose may evolve to evoke among consumers a single source, thus achieving a distinctive status.

Legal Framework Under the Lanham Act: The Lanham Act, which is the primary federal statute governing trademarks in the United States, recognizes acquired distinctiveness as a basis for registering marks that do not inherently distinguish the goods or services of one party from those of another. Section 2(f) of the Lanham Act specifically provides for the registration of marks that have acquired distinctiveness through their use in commerce. Applicants claiming acquired distinctiveness must demonstrate that their mark has become distinctive of their goods or services in the minds of the public prior to the registration.

Examination Criteria as Per the TMEP: The Trademark Manual of Examining Procedure provides detailed guidelines on how the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office (USPTO) examines claims of acquired distinctiveness. According to the TMEP, evidence of secondary meaning can include direct consumer testimony, consumer surveys, exclusivity, longevity, and the manner of the mark’s use, as well as advertising and media recognition. The USPTO evaluates whether the mark serves in the public perception as an identifier of the source of a product or service.

Factors Influencing Acquired Distinctiveness: Several factors contribute to establishing secondary meaning, including:

  • Amount and Manner of Use: The duration and nature of the trademark’s use are critical. Long-term, continuous use is a strong indicator of secondary meaning.
  • Volume of Sales and Number of Customers: High sales volumes and a significant customer base can demonstrate widespread recognition.
  • Amount and Extent of Advertising: Extensive and widespread advertising that prominently features the trademark helps build public association.
  • Geographical Usage: Use of the trademark in a wide geographical area can support claims of acquired distinctiveness.
  • Evidence of Intentional Copying: Imitation of the trademark by other businesses can be a testament to its secondary meaning, as it implies recognition of the trademark as a source identifier.

Challenges and Considerations: Obtaining trademark protection through acquired distinctiveness is not without challenges. The applicant bears the burden of proof to demonstrate that the mark has achieved secondary meaning. Additionally, this status can be difficult to maintain if the trademark’s distinctive character is not actively preserved through continued, consistent use and advertising.

Acquired distinctiveness is a powerful concept that allows trademarks, which may initially lack inherent distinctiveness, to achieve protection under the Lanham Act through their developed identity in the consumer marketplace. Understanding and proving this concept is crucial for trademark owners seeking to secure and enforce their rights over non-inherently distinctive trademarks.

Understanding How a Trademark Acquires Secondary Meaning

When a trademark primarily reminds the public of who makes a product or offers a service, rather than what the product or service is, it has acquired what is known as secondary meaning. This status is crucial for trademarks that aren’t inherently distinctive and it allows them to be registered on the Principal Register of the USPTO, gaining a wider range of legal protection.

Developing Secondary Meaning: The journey to achieving secondary meaning involves consistent and extensive use of a trademark in commerce. Over time, through continual exposure, consumers start associating the trademark with a single source or origin. The process is significantly supported by strategic advertising and promotional activities that highlight the trademark, making it stand out in the marketplace and reinforcing its association with a particular source.

Challenges and Strategies: Non-distinctive marks, which include descriptors, personal names, geographic terms, laudatory phrases, slogans, trade dress, and even certain colors, face a tougher path to secondary meaning. These marks inherently lack the immediate capability to indicate the source of a product or service. However, through focused marketing and consistent commercial use, these trademarks can overcome their inherent limitations and establish a distinct commercial identity.

Legal Recognition of Secondary Meaning: Once a trademark’s secondary meaning is well established, the USPTO may grant it registration on the Principal Register. This not only affirms the mark’s acquired distinctiveness but also extends comprehensive protections against infringement. It’s important for trademark owners to provide substantial evidence of secondary meaning, which can include consumer surveys, sales data, length and manner of use, advertising spending, and unsolicited media coverage.

In conclusion, acquiring secondary meaning is a strategic process that requires time, effort, and a keen understanding of branding. For businesses, especially those using initially non-distinctive marks, achieving this can be a significant milestone in establishing a strong market presence and securing their brand legally.

Key Requirements for Establishing Secondary Meaning in Trademarks

Establishing secondary meaning in a trademark is essential for marks that are not inherently distinctive, enabling them to qualify for federal trademark protection. This involves demonstrating that the trademark has become uniquely associated with the goods or services provided by a particular source. Here’s a detailed discussion on the requirements necessary to establish secondary meaning:

Duration of Use: A fundamental requirement for establishing secondary meaning is the duration for which the mark has been in use. Typically, a continuous use of at least five years is considered sufficient to allow a mark to develop a secondary meaning. This extended period helps ensure that the mark has been exposed to a significant segment of the consuming public long enough to create a strong association.

Distinctiveness: While the mark in question must not be inherently distinctive to require secondary meaning, it must evolve to be distinctive through its use. The mark cannot be merely descriptive of the goods or services it represents. Instead, it should have acquired a unique character that distinguishes it from other similar marks or descriptive terms in the industry.

Consumer Association: A crucial criterion is that the consuming public primarily associates the mark with the source of the goods or services rather than the goods or services themselves. This means that when consumers see the trademark, they think of the company or brand that offers the products or services, rather than the product or service category.

Advertising and Promotion: Extensive and targeted advertising and promotional efforts are vital in creating a link between the mark and the source in the minds of consumers. These efforts should be designed to highlight the trademark as a symbol of the source rather than merely promoting the products or services.

Consumer Surveys: Consumer surveys are often used as a direct method to demonstrate that a substantial portion of the target market recognizes the mark as an indicator of source. These surveys must be carefully designed to accurately measure recognition and association.

Additional Evidence: Other forms of evidence can also support the establishment of secondary meaning. This may include unsolicited media coverage, testimonials, or evidence of intentional copying by competitors, which can indicate that the mark serves as a significant identifier in the marketplace.

High Standard of Proof: The standard to establish secondary meaning is rigorous. Trademark owners must provide clear and convincing evidence that the mark has achieved a high degree of consumer recognition and is associated with the source of the goods or services. This often requires a comprehensive compilation of evidence spanning several aspects of the trademark’s use and promotion.

In conclusion, establishing secondary meaning is a detailed and often challenging process, but it is critical for protecting a trademark that lacks inherent distinctiveness. Successfully meeting these requirements can significantly enhance the legal protections available to a trademark, securing its exclusive use for the owner in the marketplace.

Contact Our Trademark Attorneys

If you need assistance with your trademark matters, whether this involves a trademark search, registration, response to an office action, opposition, cancellation, monitoring, maintenance, renewals, etc., please do not hesitate to reach out to our law firm by giving us a call or completing our online contact form.  Our attorneys will respond to all trademark inquiries within one business day.